Comments: Nationwide seals the rate hike


I think you are right, about it sealing the rate rise. However IMVHO, this is probably a lumpy number (and remember Nationwide run their data 15th to 15th), and it is approvals, rather than the "live" market.

I think the Halifax number (1s-30th), will give a better picture, however that isn't out until next thursday, so a bit late.

FWIW I wouldn't be surprised is Haifax shows a small negative number.

But that said, a blimin strong number from Nationwide. And I look forward to seeing their 2Q07 regional breakdown.

Posted by kingofnowhere at June 28, 2007 01:35 PM


In Chart 4 at foot of N'Wide report - 3 months on previous 3 months % change - pls note the slowdown from 5% pq to below 0.5% pq by 0805. That is the slowdown to which I have referred. Had the IR not been cut it would have gone -ve by Q4 or definitely 2006. And stayed there.


Posted by Jonathan Davis at June 28, 2007 07:51 PM

I don't want to start this one again but I disagree with that, because house prices operate with a lag on approvals and, as I said before, approvals were recovering long before the cut. What I would accept is that if the Bank had followed through with further cuts in 2004, or kept people thinking further hikes were in order, it could have kept a lid on the market. It didn't do so because at the time inflation was low and so, in its view, was the inflation outlook. Expectations of rate cuts started to build. Charlie Bean talks about the August 2005 rate cut on the Bank's website:

Posted by David Smith at June 28, 2007 10:47 PM

Hi Jonathan/David

I am not going to enter the debate, apart from this post, because taking over every blog, with house prices is a bit of a pain, especially to people whose lives don't revolve around HPi

Anyway, looking a HPI and approvals I would point here (DS your search doesn't work, So I had to trawl)

Read the thread on that page

Then read Sandid's link

I think that should explain enough about Approvals and HPI and there relationship

Anyway IMVHO, to cause HPI to fall (not to crash), then the BOE needed to raise rates in Feb 2005, which would have put a lid on approvals, they didn't and the market recovered. Even if the MPC didn't cut rates in Aug 05, HPI would still be running away. It was the act of not increasing borrowing (From Nov 04) that was the cause of HPI.

Posted by kingofnowhere at June 29, 2007 10:54 AM

The Government should assist the BoE by removing the tax breaks provided to those who invest in residential property. And yes, the BoE made a severe mistake when they cut IRs - they were giving out the wrong signals - something I pointed out to their agents at the time. I suggest that the BoE should hike by 0.5% in July.

Posted by Mr Naresh Radson at June 29, 2007 05:17 PM

Dear David,
I just wonder whether the MPC will hold fire next week also in line of the increasing terror threat and its possible impact on the economy. (I am not arguing that there is a history or causality here, but as we know, following the July 2005 attacks, and with inflation rising, they decided to cut from 4.75% in July to 4.5% in August).
Many thanks.

Posted by Costas Milas at June 30, 2007 08:55 PM

Apologies; it should read "also in light"
Many thanks.

Posted by Costas Milas at June 30, 2007 08:57 PM

Good point. It may well impact on their decision, particularly if there are other terrorist events over the next few days.

Posted by David Smith at July 1, 2007 09:18 AM

jonathan davis sold his property to rent in 2002 thinking prices were crashing - he wanted to speculate to buy back in cheaper later and sadly mistimed the market. he hasnt shut up about an impending crash ever since and is getting increasingly desperate. dont know why anyone listens to him.

Posted by BARRIE at November 14, 2007 06:25 PM

有些人,离我很近,但心却相隔遥远;有些人,离我很远,哪怕相隔千山万水,我们的心却贴得很近;远和近是源于一种感觉,一种心的体验。衡量人之间距离的一把尺是心wow gold,cheap wow gold,warcraft gold,wow power leveling,warcraft power leveling,Ffxi Gil,Final Fantasy Xi Gil,Guild Wars Gold,Pet products,Dog carrier,Dog Collar,Dog apparel,Dog carrier,Dog Leash,
Dog Clothes,Pet products,Dog Clothing,Lord Of The Rings Online gold ,lord of the rings gold ,2moons Dil,2moons,buy dofus kamas,sell dofus kamas,dofus kamas,buy lotro gold,lotro gold,warcraft gold,warcraft power leveling,wow leveling,礼品公司,商务礼品,礼品采购,网球场,
oil purifier,wedding dresses,wow power leveling,wow gold,World of warcraft power leveling,wow power leveling,wow gold,buy wow gold,wow gold,Cheap WoW Gold,Cheap WoW Gold,WoW Gold,wow gold,出国留学,英国留学,留学英国,扁桃体发炎,扁桃腺发炎,扁桃体炎,扁桃体化脓,传世私服,传奇世界私服,上海翻译,北京翻译,翻译公司,上海翻译公司,北京翻译公司,翻译公司,上海翻译公司,北京翻译公司,翻译公司,上海翻译公司,北京翻译公司,翻译公司,wow powerlevel,world of warcraft powerleveling,wow cd key,world of warcraft cd key,lineage2 cd key,world of warcraft cd key,lineage 2 account,lord of the rings online powerleveling,lord of the rings online gold,
promotional products,promotional items,dog products,flashlight,标志设计,,runescape money,runescape gold,环氧地坪,runescape gold,runescape money,双色球,福利彩票,
礼品,seo,seo论坛,seo软件,seo培训,yantai,chongqing, 真空滤油机,滤油机,净油设备,VI设计,工作服,西服,制服,职业装,服装设计,wholesale dog clothing,wholesale dog clothes,Dog Clothes,mesothelioma,evening gownswedding gownsformal gownsbridal gowns 美要靠距离来维持,距离是一种尊重,一种在人际间不可或缺的法则。也是友谊的基石,信任的阶梯!愿大家彼此保留一块心理空间 w9u5b7yg

Posted by wow power leveling at November 15, 2007 06:50 AM